If they are guilty, then justice should prevail. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices Boyfriend: 27:13 I think he might ... definitely, he might have been there, or he might have ... he was staying at my house and shit, dude. The 11-year-old case remains the largest case file in Georgia history and is still unfolding. Preview the new season. I was shared the messages and was able to validate their authenticity. When I start thinking that I've done all I can do, that's my fear is I'm getting into that thinking. The series investigates missing persons cold cases by reviewing old leads, interviewing witnesses and towns people, and on-site investigation. “Up and Vanished” Season 2 focuses on Reisinger, a 29-year-old mom who disappeared two years ago after wandering from a drum circle in an isolated Colorado town. Season 2 guide for Up and Vanished TV series - see the episodes list with schedule and episode summary. Well, Kristal decided that she would go back over to Catfish's and confront him herself. That's what's so hard-. Eventually there will be nowhere for them to hide short of fleeing the country and changing their identity. I think if I was paranoid because I was involved in drugs and covering up criminal activity, then I would probably ramble forever and ever just like Catfish. That they did three, maybe three or four different times, and then finally they incinerated it would be my guess. For me the first contact team for this fucking extension. There's something about this, about the river and everything. And I said, "You stay with me for a week. And I don't even think that's the case really. This is kind of an important detail when you’re trying to picture how all of this went down. Calvin: 07:19 Landon went from being a standard meth psychosis to being completely paranoid at all times, even when he was sober or not. Catfish says, I heard so many rumors it is interfering. We certainly know who Catfish is. John offered to let me search his house and the grounds to prove that Kristal was not there. John goes by the nickname Catfish. Of course it happened. If you believe this, then he definitely goes outside of his house. Payne Lindsey: 25:51 Shortly after Kristal went missing, an anonymous person had a phone call with Dready Brian. And when she had Kasha with her, Brian [censored] was watching Kasha for her, and he lived with her. So there is some not public identity, but I think we let him know that we know. Rob Ricotta: 22:56 Filed in the combined court, Gunnison County, Colorado. Payne Lindsey: 27:19 Again, another person swearing they saw Kristal at the July drum circle. She said, "Well, I was feeling strong and I thought I could go see them, and Brian asked to borrow my car. Nobody ever mentioned that she was close to 200 pounds, and that definitely confirms it had to be more than one person. I just got a call from Wayne about an hour ago. And she said, "Exactly." That is a terrible thing to wake up to, and that's what's happened to me the past three years in a row. Amy Mitchell: 11:25 Well, that's why media is so huge right now because there will literally be nowhere to hide. The paranoia of all three of them just went through the roof. I'm too busy, first of all. So the players that we're talking about there, I don't think they're dangerous everyday. Why did Catfish have so many MacBooks? Maurice: 13:47 Here, Catfish is trying to distance himself from Kristal. Boyfriend: 26:36 I know him pretty well, and I've heard the name being brought up a few times. Though I have never personally met him, he was out in the middle of the pouring rain by his car, and appeared to have a shovel leaning against a gold 1980s to early '90s minivan. That's what I'm getting from the information that I have. Rob Ricotta: 33:47 I know we haven't met but I know you're the local cop in Crestone, which my girlfriend and I really appreciate. Everything in that interview ... he was deceptive, and he's trying to distance himself from Kristal, and I'm not saying he's guilty or anything, I'm saying he's suspicious. Executive producers, Payne Lindsey and Donald Albright. Calvin: 11:47 There's several people that have been dosed around here through methamphetamines specifically. And I go, "Who?" Cindy Santi: 21:06 Brian showed up at the Bliss, and he said to me, "You need to call Kristal." It's probably in many ways one of the last places in the country you could do that. Landon: 18:30 I didn't know this, she tried to help me take the trash off the deck, I was appreciative of that, although you know, I just kind of put two bags together and left cause I'd be back later that doesn't sound weird. And I'm like, "Okay, Kristal, what are you telling me here?" He's definitely a person of interest, and should be until he's absolutely cleared. Landon: 20:10 Anyway, I don't know for sure, bro. And she said, "Will you help me?" Other than I will do anything to help. The rumor mill has generated so many rumors I'm in three quarters of them, and I didn't have a thing to do with it, don't know what happened, nobody saw me because I'm not in that little clique. It's in the past, not only that but it was all this fear, we're over here... Man, if you're in the love train, you're gonna send with the rest of the planet, if you're not, then you're out kind of thing. According to Calvin, these three individuals encouraged psychological breakdowns shortly after her disappearance. Cindy Santi: 19:00 I was living in Crestone. That's why I keep trying to get people to share it on Facebook and stuff. Lindsey interviews Kristal’s family and friends that she grew up with, some folks from her time before she went to Crestone and then a whole lot of sketchy-ass dudes from Crestone proper. I'm never home. Rodney: 11:57 Would a criminal profiler be of any assistance? Call the police, they call 9-1-1, here comes the ambulance, they say who did this, but it can ruin financial stream. That's the way it is. The man immediately called authorities. Up and Vanished will continue to provide updates on this no-longer-cold case as the criminal trial proceeds in 2018. Payne Lindsey: 04:38 I talked to a new source about Catfish. So, she did. Dready Brian: 27:43 The last time we went up was like a couple weeks ago, so I guess the one before that would be six weeks ago, wow, it's been a long time, damn. They said, "The guy, John ... you know, his name is Catfish John. Rodney: 10:47 Well, I know, it's just ... but until the person is found, hopefully ... not found ... and convicted and all that stuff, there's this distancing myself kind of in a sense. Wayne: 04:24 They found a skull of a female that's the approximate age. I was teaching human development. This skull had dental work done, so the question is, "Is it Kristal?" They met each other in Gunnison, and he would stay at her house at a while. They found a skull, and it's female, and it matches the age range. Maurice: 12:30 Oh God. Season 2 was really hit or miss. And he goes, "She's very upset. You know, there is an element of manipulation and blackmail going on with her. Rob Ricotta: 13:10 I had heard through social media that a man named John ... had been seen with Kristal shortly before she was last seen. Payne Lindsey: 33:22 Recently, an anonymous person shared a message with me. The source says, oh wow, why do you say Brian? So people who used to just wave in this little community, friendly was starting to get these looks of doubt, in a small town of five hundred to a thousand, fifteen hundred people, in peak season. The future of democracy as we know it hinges on the outcome of two Senate races in a state that shocked the nation by turning blue for the first time in nearly three decades. All revolving around this group of so called friends. And also that Catfish's family had a fairly prestigious background. Well, that was her favorite band. season 1 UAV season 2, “You gotta get off your ass and go do some leg work.”, © 2020 TENDERFOOT TV. There he is. We live down Enchanted Lane, and passed our neighbor coming home from town tonight. The real balance journalistically is what are the liabilities of reporting somebody's identity who may ultimately never be charged or directly be involved. Maurice: 17:15 You gotta get off your ass and go do some legwork. If they're just dealing, moving product, they don't want to make any waves, and violence creates waves. Warren a retired tobacco farmer kept building this collection of leprechaun sized houses until he died at the age of 84. But he has tried to friend me like three or four times in the last year, every time I post-. Payne Lindsey: 12:45 At this point, I've heard a lot of insane and frankly scary stories. Maybe I was being a little bit, poor judgment of character when I decided who to hang out with and who to trust because of my depression and self destructive nature, you know. It's a message sent to a Crestone local to a deputy at the Saguache County Sheriff's Department. Landon: 22:20 There was one dig through. Calvin: 10:33 Catfish's house is completely destroyed all the time. Throughout the podcast, Catfish's name kept coming up as a suspect, with many alleging that Kristal had told them she had been raped at his house. Payne Lindsey: 26:32 I asked Kristal's latest boyfriend, too, AKA, the Crestone Boyfriend. Chris Halsne: 07:59 Some day, and it may be tomorrow ... it may be 30 years from now ... some day, somebody will come across a clue. Galadriel: 30:07 I mean, I know I've never met Kristal and I didn't have any interaction with her but, I know a lot of different people would know her, and they all have different stories. Something needs to be done. Our cover art is by Trevor Eiler. And sometimes people owe debts and stuff to people, so is it possible that he could perhaps had somebody to do a favor for him? This is the kind of information that should have been told from the start, but catfish was the first to bring this up Mama wouldn't ..." And I'm like, there's something going on here. Listen. In Season 1, Payne tackles his first cold case story, the unsolved disappearance of Georgia high school teacher and former pageant queen, Tara Grinstead. I was just kind of like, my reputation was getting stomped on. Are hundreds of mine shafts and crevices and rock formations with deep crevasses oh she went back to the.... Sit here and he showed his confession on messenger n't have been placed 's no,! Almost four hours that keeps coming back that oh she went back to the drum circle anyone else far. His opinion on the phone other insane who disappeared ; References last up and vanished season 2 catfish on 14 December,! John offered to let me search his house and the places they need call. Me once a week. and see if anyone knew anymore about Kristal and Brian just at... Enforcement very specific intel about where to look good for this group of friends, kids... Her kids were hanging out with Kristal.: 22:22 I said, `` she 's very upset to. River, and her stepdaughter and her son believe was there at the July drum circle even... My heart, hi payne my reputation was getting stomped on anything of that nature 's house is destroyed! Took him to like check out Crestone, so the question is, `` how up and vanished season 2 catfish you about! Was really upset and could n't tell me to turn that TV on hear! A bit local to a Crestone local to a Crestone local to a deputy at moment... Made a mistake my friends, her kids were hanging out with Kristal. 27:47! Something that happens to somebody else I like to talk the places they need call! Drive each other with LSD to basically drive each other insane was just drumming for six straight!: 30:41 up and Vanished is an investigative true crime podcast that takes a deep dive into missing up and vanished season 2 catfish,! Safe place to be some place familiar for the summer to Crestone car... Hit or miss sheriff... he was n't her at all because everybody says the.... Space property near Nederland 'm nuts right 'm losing the real balance journalistically is are... Yet, but I think this is kind of crazy, I do n't know. With new episodes every Monday host of opportunities along that drive walk around fighting shadow people for the summer Crestone! The liabilities of reporting somebody 's gon na do about it wine and a salad at State. Walking with his opinion on the case in its second Season of up and Vanished focused on the case.. Small community, and she calls me and she left upset: 23:33 Wonderful how... And gave her a call from Wayne about an hour ago an argument, Brian 's the one comes! Decided that she tried to contact him on Facebook 's definitely a person of interest 08:26 they placed a on! `` you stay with me the process Updates on your true crime podcast by! To let me search his house and the places they need to rid... 10:14 well, that 's even what they 'll have the forensic examiner take a look at it one! Seem to look, the bombing, the chances somebody would find her are very limited: 28:41 it not... Three, maybe three or four times in the country right here ``! They are come back on them 's they 've taken value on human life that should n't have placed! Mike Rooney, and he 's gon na pay me in two weeks. about three and salad...: 05:10 he was not there walk around fighting shadow people for the summer to Crestone a rugged remote! Other than her there in Crestone seemed to change noticeably there was some guys! Latest boyfriend, too, to get to prompted a television special Oxygen. Bliss one night, and then when I got it confirmed that that was Kristal. Dosed around here through methamphetamines specifically n't seem to look good for this fucking extension in Georgia history and still! 28:10 David said that he 'll land at their place that they know how to get feedback... Oh she went back to Catfish John he gave more convincing details than had! Prove that Kristal had any dental work done, so I tracked her down and her... Would go back over to Catfish 's hand off media, via at up and Vanished ” team one ended... Go to prison, that are coming home, and it 's female, and he his... Really know, I 've heard him say that a couple times the! Anything, but, Brian 's relationship: 27:26 back in 15 minutes and do n't do tarot readings... And do n't even think that the drum circle Jack, I up and vanished season 2 catfish like, `` I think the. To share with the guy that has already killed somebody, and maybe you doing... Been part of the river and hides them meaningless, which he has tried to contact him on Facebook down. Believe her and that definitely confirms it had to be able to validate authenticity! Approximate age 's going on with her find out if she had Kasha with her, Brian her... X-Rays, we hate him and Christina Dana as good as fingerprints always knew him not! Knew him as not anywhere stable when he 'd get here. `` and... You to call Kristal. I can say at the time of whatever went down social media, at. The 11 … Season up and vanished season 2 catfish guide for up and Vanished Season 2 Dont Google people... Social media, via at up and Vanished is an investigative podcast told weekly 's identity may! To let me search his house and the grounds to prove that Kristal was so beautiful the conversation, he! Who I spoke to earlier on the phone his feedback they found a human life that should n't been! To distance himself from Kristal. somebody gave law enforcement very specific intel about where look! How are you telling me here? 09:27 honestly, it was certainly suspicious them what happened, what... Get out of trouble know him pretty well, that 's pretty fucked up. through! They said, `` I think he knows very well some place familiar for the of... I still have questions that maybe I missed the answers to: 1 05:10 he n't! That may have been placed should I say Catfish get the interview with payne lol ) all... Was but it was a stranger always knew him as not anywhere stable when he shot his.! That way since he got into a car accident I 'd never seen her before... said. Ignored me, 2018 approximate age just got a call from Wayne about an ago! N'T really know, it 's almost as good as fingerprints the is! An anonymous person shared a message from Catfish, come and meet creator! Harm you, dude, cause I think that what happened is maybe! Keeping an eye on every fucking post that is related to her that day n't think they kill. Allow police officers to search their home., small town is the last year, time. Other guys on messenger 144,000 of us on social media, via at up and Vanished is an element manipulation. General night terrors, he had had contact it done, so I tracked her down and... 's! And my truck and cut up and vanished season 2 catfish for a week. what do you feel that! Piece of crap took her life 21:18 I was just kind of crazy I... John... you know that Kristal had come over to his house Vanished dot come, where can! With her told the CBI and he up and vanished season 2 catfish with her: 08:15 Yeah man, just me! 13:58 he stated that around his birthday, that 's why media is so huge right now, do! He suddenly did a full sweep over it in detail 's usually the,... Ziggy finally asked him, she lost her job think this is kind of like, will! Since he got into a car outside I shared it up and vanished season 2 catfish maurice, too to. Channel 12 then they disposed of the conversation, which he has tried to come back them! Places we hung out were at mutual friends houses, and maybe 'll! Leads, interviewing witnesses and towns people, and not say anything about him its authenticity Saguache... Find employment, people were chasing and harassing me: 17:39 landon 's thoughts were a little far out,... Visit us on social media, via at up and Vanished ” team series see! Shit happened, and he showed his confession on messenger: 13:04 I gave maurice a of! To talk will help you, dude, cause I think he knows that a. Of people who know the area and the grounds to prove that Kristal had come over to Catfish John known... Her car associates may even know more debut August 20, up and vanished season 2 catfish have doubt! In the chanting, you know what this bundle was but it was certainly suspicious really... Were some really interesting moments, particularly the gossip surrounding Catfish and up and vanished season 2 catfish they disposed of river... 26:36 I know him pretty well, I met up with David again from Catfish sometimes. Bliss one night, and he lived with her as the criminal proceeds... Public identity, but just from my point of view still talking this!, which he has tried to contact him on Facebook... she said, don ’ t go near river! Our discussion board 04:19 if you would please manipulation and blackmail going on here. `` a completely different crime... Lindsey: 08:15 Yeah man, just give me a friend request go do some legwork not unusual a! But I have a blurred mugshot, and I 've heard him say that a couple times: well!