He was one of the four hosts of a political talk show named The Cycle. Ari Melber Body Measurements: Height, Weight. ", "Drake Posts MSNBC's Ari Melber Quoting Him For The First Time To Address Capitol Insurrection Hearings", "Why Does MSNBC's Ari Melber Have So Many More Viewers Than CNN's Wolf Blitzer? He obtained a BA in political science from the University of Michigan after graduating from high school. Ari Melber emerges as a prominent American lawyer, and he won Emmy award and a well-known journalist. His Show 'The Beat with Ari Melber' Melber replaced Susteren because of his high viewer rating and qualifying background to host a mainstream show. Here he was an editor of the Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy and interned at New York County Defender Services, a Manhattan public defenders office. He is an Emmy award-winning journalist, host of The Beat with Ari Melber, and Chief Legal Correspondent for the network. Well, if youre all set, here is what we know about Ari Melber to date. Who is Ari Melber? He had received one award, i.e., Emmy Award for his Supreme Court coverage. Melber's Age & Family. Ari is known for the best reports, which he gives to the viewers. Ari Melber (Ari Naftali Melber) was born on 31 March, 1980 in Seattle, WA, is an American television journalist. His grandparents are Jewish 'Holocaust' survivors of the Second World War. Melber also served as a political writer for many publications like The Nation, The Atlantic, Politico, and The Daily Beast. Ari was married to Drew and the two stayed together for four years. Being a member of a minority group, he experienced some bullying as a young child. Ari had never believed that he would be famous after some years for his journalism. 1.80 m) tall, as he is a man of average stature. Watch highlights from Wednesday's The Beat with Ari Melber. Ari had learnt lots of things from his mistakes only as he had done work in other channels also. The part that won't actually continue to be successful. Melber was named their chief legal correspondent in April 2015. However, theygot a divorcein 2017. The Beat was compared to other news shows in a June 2020 article by conservative writer Tiana Lowe entitled Ari Melber on MSNBC conducts a excellent straight news hour., Amber Ajami Age, Wiki, Net Worth, Height, Boyfriend, Janai Norman Age, Wiki, Net Worth, Height, Husband, Molly Line Age, Salary, Net Worth, Height, Husband. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. This is the YouTube page for Ari Melber, Emmy-Award-winning anchor of "The Beat with Ari Melber" on MSNBC. In addition, his writing has been published by The New York Times, The Washington Post, and The Atlantic. container.style.maxHeight = container.style.minHeight + 'px'; The journalist has gained fame and wealth through his show, The Beat with Ari Melber, and as the chief legal correspondent for MSNBC. Barbara and Daniel Melber welcomed Ari Naftali Melber into the world on March 31, 1980 in Seattle, Washington, in the United States. She is a Canadian actress mostly known for playing Superman's love interest, Lana Lang, on the TV series Smallville. He believes that he can do everything by himself. Later, Abrams said that Ari has the mental clarity and written accuracy that make a brilliant lawyer. In January 2021, The Beat was No. [72], Video (18:49): "Inside Trump's Election Plot", Last edited on 18 February 2023, at 16:41, United States House Committee on Ways and Means, "Ari Naftali Melber Lawyer Profile on Martindale.com", "The Wild and Weird History of MSNBC's 6 PM Hour Which Now Has a Record-Holding Host", "The daily edition of 'The Rachel Maddow Show' is coming to an end. Ari Naftali Melber[1] (born March 31, 1980) is an American attorney and journalist who is the chief legal correspondent for MSNBC and host of The Beat with Ari Melber. All the professors were having a good impression of him. The Beat has over 1.8 million viewers on average which is more than CNN viewers at 6 pm. He started working as a lawyer full-time and took on several well-known cases. Melber has an estimatednet worthof$4 million. He turned down the offer, however. "[43] In April 2019, United States House Committee on Ways and Means Chairman Richard Neal carried out that plan.[44]. Ari was raised in Seattle alongside his brother Jonathan Melber, whos today a successful author, by their father Daniel M. Melber whos an Israeli immigrant, and their mother Barbara D. Melber; Aris paternal grandparents were Holocaust survivors. Spread the love. He gained popularity among the public after he received Emmy Award in 2016 for his report on the Supreme Court. Ari was ready to work again for his parents as they were his family. [27], He has won an Emmy Award for his Supreme Court coverage.[28]. He is 5 feet 11 inches tall and weighs 72kg. Ari Melber Family Details: Father: Daniel M. Melber Mother: Barbara D. Melber Spouse: Drew Grant (2014-2017) Children: Not yet Siblings: Unknown. var lo = new MutationObserver(window.ezaslEvent); Ari Melber Wife, Children, Divorce. Upon finishing college, he moved to Washington DC where he worked for Senator Maria Cantwell. Ari Melber stands to a height of 5 feet and 11 inches (1.80 meters). Real Name/Full Name Ari Naftali Melber Nick Name/Celebrated Name: Ari Melber Birth Place: Seattle, Washington, U.S. He was very much busy with all the study-related things that he never found time for. He had worked very hard for the best things, which he does believe will add effect in the future. Aris show has become one of the most famous and most viewed shows online. After this, Ari had thought not to marry anyone. tv The Beat With Ari Melber MSNBC March 3, 2023 3:00pm-4:00pm PST . Ari Melber Education: Cornell Law School (2009), University of Michigan (2002) And he is also both mentally and physically fit, He currently stands at a good height of 5 feet 11 inches or 1.8 meters. Also know more about the early life, career, net worth, relationships, and controversies of other journalists and attorneys including Anderson Cooper,Savannah Guthrie,Megyn Kelly,Seth Abramson, and Cheryl Burton. His mother Barbara is a sociologist by profession who obtained her degree from the University of Chicago. Her Husband, Kids, Cause of Death, Now, Who Is Jaimy Jackson? Body description- Height, Weight. It eventually blossomed into being named their Chief Legal Correspondent in April 2015. Additionally, Ari lives in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn. Melber attended Garfield High School, Seattle, Washington, and the University of Michigan where he graduated with an AB degree in political science. Drew Grant was the subject of his divorce after their marriage. Height. Morgan Brennans (CNBC) Wiki, Age, Height, Husband, Salary, Chrissy Metzs ex-husband Martyn Eaden Bio: Weight Loss, Net Worth, Marriage, Family, Age, Lisa Maria Boothes Bio Salary, Divorce, Ethnicity, Affairs. She previously served as a teacher atthe University of Washington and Boston University. As a chief Legal Correspondent for MSNBC, he covers the Justice Department, Supreme Court, FBI, and legal issues. The Beat airs weeknights at 6 p.m. on MSNBC. Subscribe to MSNBC: http://on.msnbc.com/SubscribeTo. He joined The Point in 2016, and by 2017 he was successful in increasing the viewer's rating by 124%. Melber did his studies at Garfield High School. Just FYI", "Conversation with Ari Melber packs Alliance campaign event", "Is Ari Melber the future of cable-news anchors? Naftali attended Garfield High School, Seattle, Washington. How tall is Ari Melber ? American journalist and attorney Ari Naftali Melber works in both fields. The journalist received the Emmy Award for hisSupreme Court coverage too. In the year 2020, Tiana Lowe had written about Ari that he is one of the best Journalists, and his shows are loved by most people. Social Media- Twitter, Instagram . Girlfriends List, Dating Lee Hangyul Wiki: Age, Height, Tattoo, Girlfriend, Cornell Law School, University of Michigan, Himself - Co-Host / Himself - Guest Co-Host / Himself - Go-Host, Himself / Himself - Guest / Himself - Guest Host. Ari Melber, an Emmy Award-winning journalist, writer and attorney, is the host of "The Beat with Ari Melber" airing nightly at 6pm ET on MSNBC. He has recently launched his TikTok account, but is yet to upload any videos onto it; Aris still followed by more than 1,000 people on the network. As this topic had arisen a lot of time but he had never replied, but he states that he is a straight person. Drew Grant previously worked as a staff writer and is currently working as Arts and Entertainment editor. He was one of the first journalists to address the issue, and as a consequence, an inquiry was launched in May 2017 to look into the situation as well as other instances of judicial obstructiveness. Sources reported the two first came across on a public occasion in 2010 and dated for a few years before they exchanged their vows. He married the American journalist and author Drew Grant in 2014, in a private ceremony attended by only a couple of their closest friends and family members; Drew holds a Bachelor of Arts degree from Oberlin College, and has worked for Observer, Forbes and Bunny Ears, amongst other publications. window.ezoSTPixelAdd(slotId, 'adsensetype', 1); Drew Grant and her ex-husband Ari Melber met for the first time as fellow journalists in 2010 and married in 2014 after four years of . Ari stands at a height of 5ft 11 in (1.8 m). In overall viewers, it outperformed CNN. [64], In 2022, Melber did a special report on the song "God Did" by Jay-Z and DJ Khaled,[65] with "acutely detailed dissection" of his verse, and Jay Z then released audio of Melber's report as a new Jay-Z track, "Hov Did," on streaming music platforms. Wedding & Marriage / Husband / Engaged / Spouse / Partner. Melber is an Emmy-award-winning journalist, writer, and attorney currently hosting The Beat with Ari Melber nightly at 6 pm ET on MSNBC. In addition to hosting political talk programs, Ari Melber also hosts shows on the arts and has hosted celebrities including rappers 50 Cent and Method Man as well as actors Sean Penn and Winston Duke. He took part in a performance about the court system while he was a third-grader attending a nearby school. MSNBC took note of his work and asked him to serve as a guest host. He was quite busy with all the things which he was doing. They exchanged vows around 2013 and, years later, for some unexplained reasons, called off their union. Drew Grant previously worked as a staff writer and is currently working as Arts and Entertainment editor. No other information regarding his family background is available. He has been referred to be Mark Zuckerbergs chief critic in the harshest terms. Melber was born on 31 March 1980 in Seattle, Washington, United States. They got married in 2014 but later divorced in 2017. Ari Naftali Melber is an American attorney and journalist who is the chief legal correspondent for MSNBC and host of The Beat with Ari Melber. (adsbygoogle=window.adsbygoogle||[]).push({}); Upon earning his J. D., Ari interned at New York County Defender Services, and was between 2009 and 2013 employed at Cahill Gordon & Reindel. [52], Melber conducted several newsworthy interviews[53] with former Trump aide Peter Navarro, and one of the interviews was cited as evidence by Congress to hold Navarro in contempt, which led to his DOJ indictment. Well, Ari Melber's age is 42 years old as of today's date 23rd February 2023 having been born on 31 March 1980. However, his work on TV isn't the only way he likes to deliver the news. Talking about his father Daniel, the old man was born and raised in Israel. ins.style.width = '100%'; How tall is Ari Melber ? Ari hasnt disclosed the reason behind their divorce. Alexandra Daddario has a decent net worth of $8 million. He also rose to fame for criticizing James Comeys dismissal from the FBI, warning that it would result in obstruction of justice. He also published political pieces at the same time for publications including The Atlantic, The Nation, Reuters, and Politico. He soon received a call from MSNBC, a news outlet, asking him to participate as a guest presenter on their program. Jonathan initially started workingas an arts-and-entertainment lawyer in New York. Ari enjoys watching movies late at night, and his favorite actors and actresses are Johnny Depp, Helena Bonham Carter and Julia Roberts, while a couple of his favorite movies are the franchise Pirates of the Caribbean, Edward Scissorhands and Fight Club. Meanwhile, Ari landed a job as an editor at the Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy. He co-hosts the program The Beat with Ari Melber and serves as MSNBC's top legal reporter. He also interviewed many important politicians in his show The Bear with Ari Melber, including former Sheriff Joseph Michael Joe Arpalo, Kamala Harris and Meek Mill. Ari Melber Height. Currently, Ari Melber holds a position of an executive legal correspondent in the MSNBC network and hosted a show of The Beat with Ari Melber, released in 2017, on 24 July. READ ALSO: Kristin Kreuk's bio: age, height, ethnicity, partner, net worth . His decision to leave the practice of law and embrace journalism was motivated by his conviction that a journalist can significantly alter the legal and criminal justice systems. She was not ready to leave Ari but was not like him anymore. | Books", "This week's NYT nonfiction paperback best seller list features three publishers' editions of the 1/6 report; Harper's edition with a foreword by @AriMelber ranked #1", "MSNBC Correspondent Ari Melber Uses Rap Lyrics to Get His Point Across XXL", "Viral Clip Shows MSNBC Pundit Appropriately Citing Gucci Mane During Segment On Trump Blavity", "Ex-Bad Boy Shyne Says His Political Addresses Are Like Rapper Bars: 'It's A Lot Of 16s', "How MSNBC Created a Cable-News Addiction Epidemic", "Nevuary w/ Ari Melber | Music's (@nevuaryradio) profile on Instagram 134 posts", "Grammy Awards' Rap Race: Can Anyone Best Kendrick Lamar? Untold Facts, Cacee Cobb Actor Donald Faisons Wife is Jessica Simpsons BFF, Inside The Life Of Kathie Lee Gifford Boyfriend Randy Cronk: His Marriage, Net Worth, Melber Raised in a Family of Multi-Talented People, Ari Melber Education: Is a University of Michigan Graduate, Joined MSNBC as a Chief Legal Correspondent, Who Is Bhad Bhabie Bodyguard Frank Dellatto? Benjy studied journalism at Goldsmiths University of London, graduating in 2009. Following the immense success of the program, Melber gained tremendous positive reviews from critics. He had never thought to take a break as he is quite ambitious for his work. Ari then reported that now former President of the USA Donald Trump could go for bribing Ukraine, which then happened a month later. degree in political science. He was born in 1980 in Seattle, Washington, United States. Ari with Alexandra attending an event P.C-Google. Neither Melber nor his then-Gf Alexandra disclosed when the two exactly split. Belgaum, Karnataka, India In addition, he belongs to the white heritage. He is therefore 43 years old as of 2023. He has also conducted one-on-one interviews with both special counsel Robert Mueller and Trumps political staffer Sam Nunberg. "[19] New York Times columnist Peter Wehner called him "an outstanding interviewer, among the best on television". American journalist and attorney Ari Naftali Melber works in both fields. He loves his work of journalism, and he tries to give the best to the audience. Dont Miss: List of guys Alexandra Daddario dated: Her boyfriends. Ancestry: Israeli American. She was not ready to leave Ari but was not like him anymore. Dating, Wife, Married, Parents, MSNBC, List of guys Alexandra Daddario dated: Her boyfriends. We and our partners use data for Personalised ads and content, ad and content measurement, audience insights and product development. Melber is 42 years old as of 2022. Ari Melber Height. He does his work very confidently and never feared to speak up on any wrong thing. As this topic had arisen a lot of time but he had never replied, but he states that he is a straight person. Caption: Ari Melber (Source: Pinterest) Height, Weight, Eyes Color. Ari was born on 31st March 1980, in Seattle, Wahington, United States. Plus, Melber is joined by Russian novelist Gary Shteyngart and MSNBC Host Chris Hayes for "Fallback Friday." Joyce Vance, Bill Kristol, Joan Walsh, and . Melber graduated from Garfield High School in Seattle before earning a . However, Ari Melber started to get interested in politics when he was a senior in high school. With an aim to cover the life of celebrities, he started the website in 2020 and has been continuously working as an author, editor, and administrator. Melber is of American nationality and citizenship. He has had enormous success in his role as presenter of the show The Beat with Ari Melber. The program debuted in 2017 and has since become one of the most watched news TV shows in the nation. The same year saw him work as a legal analyst on the show NBC News, and some coverages included the Supreme Court for which Ari was presented with an Emmy Award Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and the United States Department of Justice;. Parents were very much happy with the simple living and high-order thinking lifestyle. the recognition is a story, almost 60 years after colonel davis was nominated. Nick Name/Celebrated Name: Ari was ready to work again for his parents as they were his family. It once attracted more viewers to MSNBC at that specific time slot than any other program in the history of the network. In early 2021, with an average of 2.6 million viewers a night, The Beat became #1 at 6 pm in ratings, topping CNN and FOX News. degree in political science. Additionally, Ari received praise for his involvement in highlighting Facebooks influence on media and international elections. Ari Melber was married to Drew Grant, an entertainment editor based in Burbank, California, United States until some point in 2017. Ari Melber spent around four years in the U.S. Senate where he served as a legislative aide. He had done his work constantly with adding lots of effect to it. In 2018, they were seen for the first time on a lunch date in Cuban restaurant Cafe Habana Malibu. Discover Ari Melber's Biography, Age, Height, Physical Stats, Dating/Affairs, Family and career updates. Weekdays, the program begins at 6 p.m. Currently, Ari Melber holds the positions of chief legal reporter for MSNBC and legal analyst for NBC News. According to research, he is weighing an average of 72kgs. Ari was born in Seattle, Washington, U.S. His father was Daniel M. Melber, and his mother was Barbara D. Melber. Melber is a legal analyst for NBC News as well as MSNBC's chief legal correspondent,[26] covering the United States Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and the Supreme Court. 1, Posts Week-to-Week Gains But Year-Over-Year Losses", "Here's Who Showed Up at The Beat With Ari Melber 5-Year Anniversary Celebration", "NOMINEES ANNOUNCED FOR THE 41ST ANNUAL NEWS & DOCUMENTARY EMMY AWARDS The Emmys", "The Beat averaged a historic 1,500,000 nightly viewers this year the most ever for MSNBC at 6pm and over 119 million more video views on YouTube than the previous year, nearly doubling views year-over-year", "Even Trump's Personal Attorney Loves MSNBC's Ari Melber", "Snoop Dogg Reacts To Seeing Old 2Pac Footage During Ari Melber Interview: 'I Feel Like Fuckin' Somebody Up', "MSNBC public editor: Who exactly are these people? He returned to college at CornellLaw School to earn a J.D. Both the husband and wife were living happily, but due to some reason, they had conflicts regularly. Ari's today mostly focused on hosting his show "The Beat with Ari Melber", but has also co-hosted many others for MSNBC, including "The Cycle", "The Rachel Maddow Show" and "The Nation". Ari Melber's wife, children, divorce. Hence, Ari's hair is black, and has dark brown eyes. About Luke Grimes from American Sniper: Wife, Net Jonathan Capehart's Biography: Husband Nick Schmit Jazzma Kendrick Biography: Age, Height. Melber is a host of the widely popular news and politics program,The Beat with Ari Melberon MSNBC. Ari once interviewed four witnesses in the Mueller probe case at the same time, and was in 2019 named amongst the best interviewers on TV by various magazines; he was also nominated for an Emmy for Outstanding Live Interview. Benjy has also written for DailyMail and TMZ. His expenses are not too much, and that the reason he has a great saving which resulted in this amount. His expenses are not too much, and that the reason he has a great saving which resulted in this amount. He is the chief legal correspondent for MSNBC and host of The Beat with Ari Melber. Ari Melber Height | Weight Melber stands at a height of 5'11" (1.80m) and weighs 72 kg. [10] The show has been on the air over 5 years. He followed the typical professional path for political science grads after graduating from college and worked as Senator Maria Cantwells staffer. Ari Melber and his body measurements. Maiden Name. Ari was born in Seattle, Washington, U.S. His father was Daniel M. Melber, and his mother was Barbara D. Melber. He is also a former regular contributor of Politico, The Nation, and Reuters. Legit.ng recently published an article on the biography of Kristin Kreuk. Ari Melber spoke with Corey Lewandowski, the former manager of Trumps campaign, in February 2019. FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ABOUT ARI MELBER WHO IS ARI MELBER? Hopefully he opens up about his relationship in case he is in a relationship. Melber was born Ari Naftali Melber on 31 March 1980 to parents Daniel M. Melber and Barbara D. Melber. Are all wishes were fulfilled by his parents. Ari Melber Height. Ari Melber Height. Her recent work involves hosting The Beat with Ari Melber which was launched on July 24, 2017. As of 2022, Ari Melber's net worth is $4 million. Date Of Birth/Birthday: 31 March 1980 Age/How Old: 41 years old Height/How Tall: In Centimetres - 180 cm In Feet and Inches - 5 11 Weight: In Kilograms - 72 Kg In Pounds - 160 lbs Eye Color: Brown [4] In 2022, The Beat doubled CNN's ratings. After college, Ari relocated to Washington D.C. to work for Senator Maria Cantwell. Melber got married to Drew Grant in 2014. Age, height and net worth. He mainly covers the issues of the United States Department of Justiceand the Supreme Court. Ari had dealt with many people, and he never felt to describe any topic frankly. Kai Musk (Celebrity Kid), Bio, Age, Height, Weight, Girlfriend, Family, Net Worth, Greg Gutfeld Bio, Age, Wife, Gay, Children, Height, Net Worth, Show, Books. The Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy was edited by him. Also read Nilsa Prowant Floribama Shore, career, age, net worth, relationship. Being brought up on the east side of NYC Ari reminds me off all the young men I hung out with. He developed into a highly skilled attorney while working for Abrams and studied the legal industry through and out. The former couple also appeared along with comedianRichard Lewisduring his24 years of sobriety celebration on 4th August 2018. He had left everything for some days, and then the channel wants him back. She married Ari Melber in 2014, but they divorced three years later. Ari Melber maintains his body fitness with regular workouts. He likes to read books in his spare time, and his favorite author is Milan Kundera, while his favorite books include The Unbearable Lightness of Being and The Joke. Ari Melber is not dating anyone as of 2023. He is doing all the things with all his own resources. Hisannual salaryis estimated to be$64,000. Once Alexandra sat in the drivers seat of her car, Ari leaned in for a romantic kiss. Fox News turns on its own. In the January month of 2021, his viewers were 2.6 million on average. Ari Naftali Melber is an American attorney and journalist who is the chief legal correspondent for MSNBC and host of The Beat with Ari Melber. It was one of the most successful events for their channel. He began writing political op-ed pieces for several news organizations, including The Nation, The Atlantic, Reuters, and Politico. Melber completed his undergraduate course in Seattle. The show premiered on July 24, 2017, and was nominated for a 2020 Emmy Award for Outstanding Live Interview. Having served in Capitol Hill twice, John Flannery has stated that- he has never seen anything like what happened on January 6, 2021. . Melber reported President Trump's actions toward Ukraine provided a potential case of impeachment for "bribery" in October. Ari Naftali Melber was born on March 31, 1980 in Seattle, Washington, U.S. Forbes says. Hes bight, liberal with a sense of humor. his original . Melber was appointed as their main legal reporter in April 2015. All the professors were having a good impression of him. [37], Melber broke the story[38] of police repeatedly tasing a Virginia man until he died in police custody, an investigative report[39] that led to an FBI investigation of the officers' conduct. Birth Place: How old is Ari Melber? His main source of income is his career as a journalist, an attorney, and an author. She has a good height of 173 cm or 5 ft. 8 inches. They arrived in Seattle, Washington, via some kind of immigration. 00:55. He also has an older brother named Jonathan Melber. The New York Observers pop culture correspondent is Drew Grant. Ari Melber was born on 31st March 1980, in Seattle, Washington to an American mother and Israeli-born father. Besides, he was born and grew up in Seattle, Washington D.C., in the United States of America. Ari Melber stands at a height of 5 feet and 11 inches (1.80 meters). [22] Melber was a correspondent for The Nation; and he has been published in The Atlantic, Reuters and Politico and several books; he wrote a report about Organizing for America. Here is the cover! Who is she Alicia Acuna (Fox News) Wiki Biography, age, heigh Who has Cam Newton dated? Ari Melber is an American attorney and journalist who serves as MSNBC's chief legal correspondent and hosts The Beat with Ari Melber. Aris age is 41. Ari Melber Wife | Children. Akiko Matsuura, Charlie Heatons Ex-Girlfriend-Where is She Now? More About Ari Melber. He was nominated for an Emmy Award for "Outstanding Live Interview"[12] for interviewing four key witnesses in the Mueller probe at once. Ari had married Drew Grant in the year 2014. Ari Melber is a lawyer and famed Journalist, . John Flannery Capital Riot. Further, he is also one of the Co-Founders at Pandora Group of Companies. He believes that he can do everything by himself. . Journalist Ari Melber Height, Weight, Measurements, Shoe Size, Biography Details. He also has appeared in several shows as a guest host. He also serves s the Chief Legal Correspondent and NBC News Legal Analyst. Ari Melber Age. He is said to be datingAlexandra Daddario, the Baywatch actress. Melber has drawn attention for his interviewing skills. His grandparents had survived the Second World Wars Holocaust on Jews. Keep it up young man, we this geezer will watch you until they close the lid on life! Ari had taken interviews of some of the most successful businessmen also. He also broke the tale of a Virginian man who was repeatedly tased by police before being died in jail. var alS = 1021 % 1000; He is one of the best Journalists that cannot be replaced by any other person.